Tuscai helped Immaculata to its first win of the 2013 season against Arcadia (10-8) by leading the team with three goals. Tuscai scored twice during the final five minutes to break an 8-8 tie, and lift the Mighty Macs the victory. Tuscai recorded the game-winning goal at the 4:43 mark, which also eclipsed the 100-point mark for his career.